Expected 10-Year Returns for Major World Markets

Research Affiliates, the research firm led by “smart beta” pioneer Rob Arnott, recently created a great research tool that enables you to choose any eight world markets and compare their valuations.  Research Affiliates then takes it a step further by forecasting the expected return over the next 10 years based on those valuations.  For those who like to delve into the nitty-gritty details, the forecasting methodology is explained here.   Estimates are exactly that: estimates.  Real-world results will almost certainly look a lot different than these estimates suggest, but this gives us a nice “quick and dirty” way to gauge how attractively priced a given country is.

As you might suspect, after the run we’ve had since early 2009, the U.S. is priced to deliver pretty disappointing returns over the next decade.  But much of the rest of the world is looking pretty attractive.

(Incidentally, Meb Faber’s Idea Farm alerted me to this. If you don’t already subscribe to Idea Farm, I highly recommend you do.  It’s a never-ending stream of fantastic resources like these.)

As an example, I chose the following eight markets: the developed markets of the United States, Australia, Spain, the United Kingdom and the emerging markets Brazil, China, India and Russia:

Research Affiliates CAPE

Don’t be intimidated by graphics in the bottom-most graph.  Essentially, this graph compares today’s valuation (“CAPE” or “Shiller P/E”) to the historical norm by country.  The blue dot is today’s valuation and the yellow box is what you might consider a “normal” range.

Certain countries–such as India–would appear expensive at first glance but are actually still below their long-term averages.  Others–such as Spain, Brazil, China, and Russia–are below their “normal” ranges and would thus appear to be absolute bargains with expected annual returns after inflation of 6.5% to 13.8%.

The one outlier here is, of course, the United States.  You’ll notice that the blue dot is well above the yellow box that indicates a normal valuation range.   Because of this high starting point, Research Affiliates expects inflation-adjusted returns of less than 1% per year over the next decade, which is actually less than the current dividend yield.  In other words, don’t expect much in the way of capital appreciation from an S&P 500 index fund.

And what about the cheap markets of Spain, Brazil, China and Russia?

All are cheap for a reason, of course.  Spain is still suffering from the fallout of the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis, Russia is the target of Western sanctions and is getting battered by falling crude oil prices, Brazil is suffering from low growth and a lack of competitiveness, and China is sitting on a demographic timebomb from its aging population.  Yet these are precisely the times that should excite a value investor.  Valuations are cheap and expectations are low.

Is there short-term risk in any of these “problem” markets?  Obviously yes.  But an intrepid contrarian should use any short-term dips as a buying opportunity for what I expect to be a fantastic decade in non-U.S. equities.

Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA, is the chief investment officer of the investment firm Sizemore Capital Management. Click here to receive his FREE weekly e-letter covering top market insights, trends, and the best stocks and ETFs to profit from today’s best global value plays. 

Comments { 0 }

Running a Financial Advisory Practice in the Age of the Robo-Advisor

Here’s a novel idea: Advisors might actually need to earn their advisory fees in the years ahead.  With the arrival of online financial planning sites like Mint.com and robo-advisors like Covestor, which allow an investor to mimic the trades [...] Continue Reading…

Comments { 0 }

Financial Planning Moves to Make After the Correction

Aren’t corrections fun?  As we suffer through our first real correction, a lot of investors are scared. There is this nagging feeling that the outsized gains of recent years were somehow “fake,” the result of central bank manipulations and [...] Continue Reading…

Comments { 0 }

This Week’s Sizemore Insights: Should You Fear the MLP Correction?

Last week, I promised to give you more details on the changes I made to my Dividend Growth Portfolio. I’m going to hold off on that promise until next week in order to tackle a more timely subject that has [...] Continue Reading…

Comments { 0 }

Senior Housing Properties: A 7% Yielder Backed By the Graying of America

In an ideal investment, you’ll have several overlapping investment themes come together.  And that’s what I see today in Senior Housing Properties Trust (SNH), one of the biggest players in the senior housing segment with 372 properties spread across 38 [...] Continue Reading…

Comments { 0 }

This material is provided for informational purposes only, as of the date hereof, and is subject to change without notice. This material may not be suitable for all investors and is not intended to be an offer, or the solicitation of any offer, to buy or sell any securities.